Experience is what causes a person to make new mistakes instead of old ones.
I agree with Martha Beth Lewis PhD, that: "musicians without sight-reading skills are hampered in all they do. As she can confirm, approaching new work has become a hassle. At a progressed stage picking up a piece of pop music will become a chore and learning it will be equivalent to learning a piece of the standard repertoire. It's no fun to "go shopping" for new pieces. Many entertaining options will not be easily accessible: accompanying, playing duets and ensembles, playing "requests" for family members and friends. All "students" need to learn to sight-read! … Sight-reading, also called sight-playing, is a learned skill, although many professional musicians don't remember how they learned to do it."
The ability to read a musical phrase at sight is considered invaluable by the vast majority of musicians. My piano tutor was surprised when I said I could not read notes. Her first reaction was to say that I had to learn them; otherwise I would be unable to progress at the speed I had been progressing so far; Not only this, but exploring new music would be almost impossible.
I started researching the topic, but did not find much on the question at to "why". Reading a few books, some information on the Internet and having my own light bulbs going on, I figured the following:
While I am far from the latter, I can only agree as I said before and elsewhere: sight-reading (as slow as I may be; currently [Aug 26th, 2007] reading bass & treble clef notes without accidentals at 1.3 seconds [median] per note) has already enabled me to learn the pieces (in the fourth quarter) of my Hal Leonard: Adult Piano Method — Lessons, Solo, Technique & Therory, Book 1.
Traditional methods of learning to sight-read often require a teacher to spend long periods of time with the student, giving feedback and correction. The student is encouraged to practice sight-reading at home, but here s/he is deprived of the feedback of the teacher. Many students learn the piece they are reading through repetition, so that after a few times through, they are not really practicing reading anymore, but are playing the piece from memory.
Prevalent misconceptions regarding sight-reading are:
Nevertheless, many musicians who have a good sight-reading ability agree that the only secret to this skill is lots of practice. I am convinced that the correction of sigh-reading deficiency must take utmost priority in musical education. Sight-reading does not only enable to grasp the piece as a whole, it also trains the memory and sharpens concentration.
Well, I thought I did a bit, but later learned that I am doing note-reading, not sight-reading. Because of that, I have moved my note-reading approach off this page in July 2008.
I have also removed this section — as described above. In essence: I have now plans to practice sight-reading on a daily basis, and be it only for ten minutes. Yes, the practice schedule gets bigger and bigger. Ear Training is another important thing that has to go onto my daily practice schedule too.
* Bernstein, Seymour, With Your Own Two Hands: Self-Discovery Through Music, (Paperback), p. 40.
Sorry, there are currently no moderated / approved entries for this page.
Start the ball rolling by posting a comment on this article!
Please note: The comments are moderated, meaning you can make one post, which will be reviewed, and if deemed appropriate, it will be published. Once it has been published, only then can you make another post.
Any subsequent post (without having one prior post published) will be discarded.
This is a SPAM-prevention measure, which may be inconvenient for some, has been proven to be very effective.
Feel free to leave a comment. Fields marked with * are required.
Please note: Your comment will NOT appear straight away. It will be reviewed prior to be listed here.
“Old traditional finger teaching excluded adequate participation by every part of the body rightfully concerned with piano playing.”
Abby Whiteside